Independent guide to NHS Agenda for Change pay, not affiliated with the NHS 2026/27 pay figures · Updated 26 Sept 2026
Modern hospital corridor with 3D wall signage reading NHS Banding Review Appeal

NHS Banding Review and Appeal: How to Challenge Your Band

Last updated: 16 November 2026 · Figures verified against the NHS Employers 2026/27 pay circular.

Most NHS staff accept their band as a fact of life. It arrives with the job offer, it sits on the payslip, and it only becomes a question when something changes: a restructure, a new set of duties, or the slow realisation that the job you do every day is not the job the band describes. When that happens, the question is not whether the band feels fair. The question is whether the post was matched or evaluated correctly, and the Agenda for Change rules give you a specific way to ask it. That way is a banding review, and it is narrower, stricter and more useful than most staff expect.

The word appeal causes most of the confusion. In ordinary language it suggests a second opinion on a decision you disagree with. In the Agenda for Change rules it means something closer to a re-examination: the same scheme, the same factors, the same evidence rules, applied again by a fresh panel. You cannot appeal because you think the band is too low in general, or because a colleague in another trust is paid more for a similar-sounding job. You can ask for a review because your post was matched to the wrong national profile, or because the local evaluation scored one or more of the sixteen factors wrongly. The distinction matters, because it decides what evidence wins and what evidence is ignored.

What a banding review is, and what it is not

A banding review is a formal re-examination of a job matching or local evaluation decision. It is set out in chapter thirteen of the NHS Job Evaluation Handbook, titled "The review process", and it sits under Part 7, Section 47 of the Agenda for Change Terms and Conditions Handbook, titled "Reviews, job appeals and evaluations". The two documents divide the work between them: Section 47 states the principles and the backdating rule, and chapter thirteen of the Job Evaluation Handbook sets out the steps, the deadlines and the limits.

The review is not a re-evaluation because the job has changed. That is a different route, for a different situation: when the duties of the post have grown substantially since it was last evaluated, you ask for a re-evaluation, and the post is scored from scratch on the current duties. The job evaluation guide explains that route, including the triggers that count and the evidence that carries weight. A review is for the opposite case: the job has not changed, but you believe the original matching or evaluation got it wrong. The two routes can look alike from the outside, because both end with a panel looking at a job, but they start from different premises, and starting on the wrong one wastes months.

The review is also not a negotiation. There is no room to bargain a band up, and no manager can award one to keep you. Bands belong to posts, and they are set by national evaluation, which is why the guide to negotiating NHS salary draws the line where it does: the starting pay step within the band can sometimes move, the band itself cannot, except through the evaluation and review machinery. A review is the one formal way to challenge the machinery's output, and it works on evidence about the job, not on arguments about the person doing it.

What one band is worth

Before the steps, it is worth knowing what is at stake, because the sums are larger than most staff guess, and they grow as you go up the scale. The table below shows the annual and monthly difference between the top of each band and the top of the next, for England in 2026/27. These are the figures a successful review would move you by if you were at the top of your current band, before pension contributions and tax. The chart plots the same annual figures, so the shape of the ladder is visible at a glance.

MoveTop of current bandTop of next bandUplift per yearUplift per month
Band 2 to Band 3£25,272£27,476£2,204£183.67
Band 3 to Band 4£27,476£31,157£3,681£306.75
Band 4 to Band 5£31,157£39,043£7,886£657.17
Band 5 to Band 6£39,043£48,117£9,074£756.17
Band 6 to Band 7£48,117£56,515£8,398£699.83
Band 7 to Band 8a£56,515£64,750£8,235£686.25
Band 8a to Band 8b£64,750£77,368£12,618£1,051.50
Band 8b to Band 8c£77,368£91,609£14,241£1,186.75
Band 8c to Band 8d£91,609£108,814£17,205£1,433.75
Band 8d to Band 9£108,814£129,783£20,969£1,747.42

The smallest step on the ladder is the first one: Band 2 to Band 3 is worth £2,204 a year at the top, or £183.67 a month. The largest early step is Band 4 to Band 5, at £7,886 a year, which is the jump from support work into registered practice. From Band 5 upwards the steps stay large: Band 5 to Band 6 is £9,074 a year, Band 6 to Band 7 is £8,398, and Band 7 to Band 8a is £8,235. Above Band 8a the steps widen sharply, because the bands themselves widen: Band 8b to Band 8c is £14,241 a year, and Band 8d to Band 9 is £20,969. A review that moves a post by one band is never a small correction, which is why the process is formal, and why the evidence bar is set where it is.

The pension effect runs alongside the pay effect. Pension contributions in England and Wales for 2026/27 are set by your actual annual pensionable pay: up to £13,259 at 5.2%, £13,260 to £28,854 at 6.5%, £28,855 to £35,155 at 8.3%, £35,156 to £52,778 at 9.8%, £52,779 to £67,668 at 10.7%, and £67,669 and above at 12.5%, with the employer paying 23.7% on top. A Band 5 nurse at the top of the band, on £39,043, pays 9.8%, which is £318.85 a month. The same nurse re-banded to Band 6 entry, on £39,959, still pays 9.8%, which is £326.33 a month, so the pension cost rises by £7.48 a month while the gross pay rises by £76.33. The pension contributions guide works through every tier, and the pension calculator projects what the extra years of higher pensionable pay are worth at retirement, which is where a successful review keeps paying long after the backdated lump sum is spent.

The three-month deadline, and the six-month trap

The single most important fact on this page is a deadline. A request for a review must be made within three months of notification of the original panel's decision. That is paragraph 1.2 of chapter thirteen of the Job Evaluation Handbook, and it is stated without qualification. The request must be in writing, it must give details of where you disagree with the match or evaluation, and it must be supported by evidence. Three months is not long, and it runs from the date you were notified, not from the date you decided the decision was wrong, so the clock can be running while you are still deciding whether to act.

The trap is a different deadline in a different document, and it has caught people before. Annex 19 of the Agenda for Change Handbook, which sets out the general local appeals procedures, says at point 5 that appeals may not be lodged more than six months after the employee was notified, or could otherwise have reasonably been expected to be aware, of the decision giving rise to the appeal. Six months sounds generous, and it is the figure many staff remember, because it appears in the main Handbook. But Annex 19 is the general local appeals framework. For disagreements about job profile matching or local job evaluations, paragraph 47.2 of the Handbook directs the parties to the Job Evaluation Handbook protocols instead, and chapter thirteen of that handbook sets its own three-month review window. The six-month limit must not be presented as the job evaluation review deadline, and it must not be relied on as one. If you count six months, you will be three months late, and the review will not happen.

Two practical consequences follow. First, ask for the matching or evaluation job report the moment you are notified of your banding, if you were not given one with the notification. Paragraph 3.5 of chapter thirteen says jobholders should be provided with a matching or evaluation job report at the time they are notified of their pay banding, and you need it to build the case: it shows which profile the post was matched to, or which factor levels the local evaluation gave, and those are the specific points your written request has to challenge. Second, check your trust's published local procedure early. Paragraph 3.2 requires the jointly agreed local procedure to be published and disseminated to all employees affected, with information about who to consult for assistance and the relevant timescales or deadlines. The national rules set the three-month window; the local procedure tells you who to send the request to, and in what form.

Step by step: how a review runs

1. Try informally first

Both handbooks expect an informal attempt before the formal machinery starts. Annex 19, point 2, says an employee who wishes to appeal must first attempt to resolve the issues informally, and that as a first step the problem should be discussed between the employee and management. Chapter thirteen adds its own informal stage, at paragraphs 1.3 to 1.7, and experience has shown it is useful: a meeting between you and a nominated person from each side, for example an HR adviser and a staff side representative, both of whom are trained matching or evaluation panel members. If you ask, your own staff side organisation representative and your line manager can be present as well.

The informal stage exists to exchange information, clarify issues, and provide an opportunity for discussion and resolution, and it can end in three ways. You may withdraw the request because you now understand and accept the original outcome, and the handbook states there must be no pressure on employees to withdraw review requests. You may come away better understanding what information the panel will require. Or you may be better able to focus on the job evaluation factors that are relevant to a review in your particular circumstances. None of those outcomes costs you the formal review: if the informal stage does not resolve the matter, the formal stage follows, and the time spent informally does not extend the three-month window, so do not let a long informal discussion eat into it.

2. Put the request in writing, with evidence

Where a formal review is necessary, it starts with your written request. Paragraph 1.2 requires details in writing of where you disagree with the match or evaluation, and evidence to support your case. That is the whole of the requirement, and it is also the whole of the case: the review panel works from the facts before it, and the facts before it are the ones you and the original documentation provide.

The strongest evidence is tied to the sixteen job evaluation factors, because those are what the panel scores. A diary of duties over two or three weeks, the job description the post was matched against with the duties that no longer fit it marked up, and concrete examples of decisions you take, people you supervise, budgets you hold, or clinical judgements you make, each linked to a factor level, will do more than a general statement that the band feels wrong. The panel is scoring a job, not a person, so evidence about how hard you work, how long you have done the job, or how much the team relies on you will not move it. Evidence about what the job demands, factor by factor, will. All the original matching or evaluation documentation, including interview notes, should be available to the review panel, so your request is judged against the same record the original panel saw, plus the new evidence you add.

3. A new panel decides

The review is conducted by a new panel, with the majority of its members different from the original panel. That is paragraph 1.1, and it is the structural guarantee that the review is a fresh look rather than the same people defending their earlier decision. The review panel operates in the same way as the original one and follows the procedure in chapter eleven for matching reviews or chapter twelve for local evaluations, with job advisers or representatives available or contactable. It is not a fresh evaluation by a different team using different rules: it is the same scheme, applied again, by people who were not part of the first decision.

The panel can reach three outcomes, set out in paragraph 1.9. It can confirm the same match or evaluation outcome. It can confirm a match to a different profile or make a different evaluation, which is the outcome you are asking for. Or, in the case of matching reviews only, it can refer the job for local evaluation, which happens when the panel concludes that no national profile fits the post well enough to match it. The panel must only consider the facts before them, under paragraph 1.10, and if it wishes to revisit factor levels you did not challenge, it has to justify doing so, for example because new evidence you provided is thought to alter other scores. It must refer to the evidence it has been presented with, put supplementary questions to the job advisers or representatives where necessary, and allow you to provide additional information. The panel should only complete the review once it is satisfied that all relevant evidence has been examined, which is a protection for you as much as a discipline for the panel: a review that rushes past your evidence has not followed the process.

4. Consistency checking before you hear the outcome

Whatever the panel decides, the decision is subject to quality and consistency checking, under paragraph 1.12, as set out in chapter fourteen of the handbook. Paragraph 3.5 states it in bold in the handbook itself: all review outcomes must be subject to consistency checking before the outcome is released to job holders. That is why there can be a gap between the panel meeting and the letter arriving, and it is a gap worth understanding rather than resenting: the consistency check is what stops two similar posts in the same trust landing in different bands because two panels scored them differently. You will be provided with a detailed job report of the review of the match or evaluation, under paragraph 1.15, so the reasoning is visible, not just the result.

What you cannot challenge

The limits on a review are as firm as the rights, and knowing them before you start saves wasted effort. First, you cannot appeal against the evaluation of a nationally profiled post. Paragraph 47.4 of the Agenda for Change Handbook states this plainly, and then states the right that exists instead: there is a right to a review on the grounds that the post does not match the national profile, but not on the grounds that the national profile is incorrect. So the argument has to be about your job and the profile, not about the profile and the band. If your post was matched to a profile and you believe the profile itself undervalues the work, that is a national matter, not a local review matter, and the local review panel cannot fix it.

Second, there is no appeal beyond the review panel on the banding outcome. Paragraph 1.13 of chapter thirteen says the jobholder has no right of appeal beyond the review panel if their complaint is about the banding outcome. The review panel is the end of the line for the band itself, and there is no higher evaluation body to go to. The one door that stays open is a grievance, and it is narrow. Paragraph 1.14 says that if you can demonstrate the process was misapplied, you may pursue a local grievance about the process, but not against the matching or pay banding decision. Where such a grievance is upheld, a potential remedy may be a reference to a new matching panel. A grievance about a process error is not a second chance at the band, and it will fail if it is really an argument that the panel reached the wrong answer.

Third, the panel can only decide on the facts before it. Paragraph 1.10 is a limit as well as a protection: the panel must only consider the facts before them, and it can only complete the review once it is satisfied all relevant evidence has been examined. Evidence you do not provide cannot be weighed, and duties that are not documented cannot be scored. Some detailed aspects of the formal review procedure are determined locally, under paragraph 1.15, for example the administration and chairing, whether you or your representatives can make your case in person, and record keeping, so the exact shape of the hearing will vary from trust to trust. The substance does not vary: the sixteen factors, the job report, and the three possible outcomes are the same everywhere.

Backdating: what a successful review is worth in arrears

Paragraph 47.3 of the Agenda for Change Handbook states that where appeals are upheld, the associated pay or benefits will normally be backdated to the date the appeal was lodged. The date that counts is the date you lodged the appeal, not the date the job changed, and not the date the review panel met. That is one more reason the three-month deadline matters: every week of delay in lodging is a week of backdating lost, because the clock for the money runs from the lodging date, not from the date the original decision was made.

Two worked examples show the scale. A Band 5 nurse at the top of the band, on £39,043, whose post is re-banded to Band 6 entry at £39,959 gains £916 a year, or £76.33 a month. If the appeal was lodged on 1 June and upheld on 1 September, three months of backdated pay is worth £229.00. A Band 5 nurse at entry, on £32,073, moving to Band 6 entry gains £7,886 a year, or £657.17 a month, so six months of backdating is worth £3,943.00. The same arithmetic applies at any band: take the annual uplift from the table above, divide by twelve for the monthly figure, and multiply by the number of months between lodging and the upheld decision.

The word normally in paragraph 47.3 deserves attention. The handbook does not promise backdating in every case, and it does not list the exceptions, so this page does not invent any. What is settled is the default: backdating to the lodging date is the normal outcome when an appeal is upheld, and any departure from it would need a reason. If your trust's local procedure says something different about backdating, ask for the reason in writing, and compare it with paragraph 47.3, because the national rule is the one that governs unless a local agreement says otherwise in terms you can see.

The national review that is not an appeal

There is one more review in the news that staff confuse with the individual process on this page, and the difference is worth stating clearly. In February 2026 the Department of Health and Social Care announced an employer-led review of every Band 5 nursing role in England, under NHS England reference PRN02508, with delivery plans due by 31 July 2026 and all roles reviewed by October 2028, and with regrading and back pay funded separately. That is a national, employer-led review of a whole group of roles, not an individual appeal, and it runs on its own timetable. The Band 5 nurse review guide covers who it affects, the timeline, and what regrading and back pay would mean. If you are a Band 5 nurse, the national review may change your band without you lodging anything. If you are not, or if you do not want to wait for October 2028, the individual review process on this page is the route that is open to you now.

The same distinction applies to the other national processes that touch banding. The NHS Pay Review Body recommends the annual pay award, which sets the cash value of every band, and the 2026/27 pay rise guide covers the 3.3% award that took effect on 1 April 2026. Job evaluation cannot raise Band 5 pay; it can only decide that your post is or is not Band 5. And a change of duties that is big enough to justify a higher band on its own is handled by re-evaluation, not by review, as the job evaluation guide explains. The three processes answer three different questions, and the review answers the narrowest of them: was this post matched or evaluated correctly, on the evidence, at the time?

Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland

The framework on this page is the UK-wide Agenda for Change framework, but the local procedures differ by nation. Annex 19 exists in two versions in the same handbook: Local appeals procedures (England), and Local appeals procedures (Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland). The numbered points quoted on this page, including the informal-first rule, the six-month general limit and the written-statement requirement, appear in both versions, so the general appeals framework is the same. The Job Evaluation Handbook chapter thirteen review process, including the three-month window and the new-panel rule, is the same process across the nations.

What differs is the pay itself, and therefore what a successful review is worth. Scotland moved to a 36-hour week in April 2026 and runs its own scale, so a Band 5 nurse in Scotland is on £34,544 to £43,039, not the England figures used in the table above. Wales pays a 3.3% award for 2026/27 with a Real Living Wage floor that lifts the bottom of the scale. Northern Ireland is different again, because the 2026/27 award of 3.3% is recommended but not yet implemented there, so staff remain on the 2025/26 scale until implementation. The Scotland pay guide, the Wales pay guide and the Northern Ireland pay guide carry the current figures for each nation, and the four-nation comparison sets them side by side. The review steps do not change with the nation, but the money at stake does, so work the uplift out on your own nation's scale before deciding whether to lodge.

Before you lodge: a short checklist

First, confirm which route you need. If the job has changed substantially since it was last evaluated, you want re-evaluation, not a review. If the job has not changed but the original decision looks wrong, you want a review. Second, get the matching or evaluation job report, and read it against your job description. The report shows what the panel decided and why, and your written request has to challenge specific points in it, not the band in general. Third, check the date. Count three months from the date you were notified of the original decision, and treat that as the deadline for the written request, not for starting to think about it. Fourth, gather the evidence, tied to the sixteen factors, with dates and examples. Fifth, talk to your staff side representative or union before you lodge, because they have seen the local procedure work and they know which arguments the local panel finds persuasive and which it dismisses. And sixth, keep a copy of everything, including the date you lodged the appeal, because that date is what the backdating runs from if you win.

One last point, and it is the one staff most often get wrong. A review is not a complaint about your manager, your trust, or the NHS. It is a request that the scheme be applied correctly to your post, using the scheme's own rules and the scheme's own evidence. The panel is not your opponent, and the informal stage is not a formality to get through on the way to a fight. The staff who succeed are usually the ones who treat it as a technical exercise: here is the job, here is the profile or the factor scores, here is where they do not match, and here is the evidence. That is the case the panel can act on, and it is the only case the rules allow it to act on.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to request a banding review?

Three months from the date you were notified of the original panel's decision. That is the deadline in chapter thirteen of the NHS Job Evaluation Handbook, paragraph 1.2, and it is a hard one: the request must be made within three months, in writing, with details of where you disagree with the match or evaluation and evidence to support your case. Do not confuse it with the six-month limit in Annex 19 of the Agenda for Change Handbook, which governs general local appeals, not job evaluation reviews. If you count six months, you will be three months late.

Can I appeal if my job was matched to a national profile?

You can request a review, but only on one ground: that your post does not match the national profile it was matched to. Paragraph 47.4 of the Agenda for Change Handbook is explicit that appeals may not be made against the evaluation of a nationally profiled post, and that there is a right to a review on the ground that the post does not match the national profile, not on the ground that the national profile is incorrect. So the argument has to be about your job and the profile, not about the profile and the band. If your job was locally evaluated rather than matched, the review looks at the evaluation itself, factor by factor.

Will my pay be backdated if the review succeeds?

Normally, yes, back to the date the appeal was lodged. Paragraph 47.3 of the Agenda for Change Handbook says that where appeals are upheld, the associated pay or benefits will normally be backdated to the date the appeal was lodged. Take a Band 5 nurse at the top of the band, on £39,043, whose post is re-banded to Band 6 entry at £39,959. The uplift is £916 a year, or £76.33 a month. If the appeal was lodged on 1 June and upheld on 1 September, three months of backdated pay is worth £229.00. A Band 5 nurse at entry, on £32,073, moving to Band 6 entry would gain £7,886 a year, or £657.17 a month, so six months of backdating is worth £3,943.00. The word normally matters: the handbook does not promise backdating in every case, and the date that counts is the date you lodged the appeal, not the date the job changed.

Who decides the review?

A new panel, with the majority of its members different from the original panel. That is paragraph 1.1 of chapter thirteen of the NHS Job Evaluation Handbook. The review panel works in the same way as the original one and follows the same procedure, chapter eleven for matching reviews or chapter twelve for local evaluations, with job advisers or representatives available or contactable. It is not a fresh evaluation by a different team using different rules: it is the same scheme, applied again, by people who were not part of the first decision.

What can the review panel decide?

Three things, set out in paragraph 1.9 of chapter thirteen. It can confirm the same match or evaluation outcome. It can confirm a match to a different profile or make a different evaluation, which is the outcome you are asking for. Or, in the case of matching reviews only, it can refer the job for local evaluation, which happens when the panel concludes that no national profile fits the post well enough to match it. The panel must only consider the facts before it, and if it wants to revisit factor levels you did not challenge, it has to justify doing so, for example because new evidence you provided is thought to alter other scores.

Is there any appeal after the review panel?

No, not on the banding outcome. Paragraph 1.13 of chapter thirteen says the jobholder has no right of appeal beyond the review panel if their complaint is about the banding outcome. The review panel is the end of the line for the band itself. The one door that stays open is a grievance, and it is narrow: paragraph 1.14 says that if you can demonstrate the process was misapplied, you may pursue a local grievance about the process, but not against the matching or pay banding decision. Where such a grievance is upheld, a potential remedy may be a reference to a new matching panel. A grievance about a process error is not a second chance at the band.

Do I have to try informally first?

Yes, in practice, and the handbooks expect it. Annex 19, point 2, says an employee who wishes to appeal must first attempt to resolve the issues informally, starting with a discussion between the employee and management. Chapter thirteen adds its own informal stage, paragraphs 1.3 to 1.7: a meeting between you and a nominated person from each side, for example an HR adviser and a staff side representative, both of whom are trained matching or evaluation panel members. If you ask, your own staff side representative and your line manager can be present. The informal stage can end three ways: you withdraw the request because you now understand and accept the original outcome, and the handbook says there must be no pressure on employees to withdraw; you come away better understanding what information the panel will require; or you are better able to focus on the job evaluation factors that are relevant to your case. None of those outcomes costs you the formal review if you still want it.

What evidence should I send with my review request?

Written details of where you disagree with the match or evaluation, and evidence to support your case: that is the requirement in paragraph 1.2, and it is the whole of the case. The strongest evidence is tied to the sixteen job evaluation factors, because those are what the panel scores. A diary of duties over two or three weeks, the job description the post was matched against with the duties that no longer fit it marked up, and examples of decisions you take, people you supervise, budgets you hold or clinical judgements you make, each linked to a factor level, will do more than a general statement that the band feels wrong. You should already hold the starting documents: paragraph 3.5 says jobholders should be provided with a matching or evaluation job report at the time they are notified of their pay banding, and all the original matching or evaluation documentation, including interview notes, should be available to the review panel. Ask for the job report if you were not given one, and check your trust's published local procedure, which paragraph 3.2 requires to be published and disseminated, with the timescales and who to consult.

Pay progression

If your review succeeds, the next question is what the new band pays. See Band 5 pay 2026/27, Band 6 pay 2026/27 and Band 7 pay 2026/27 for the scales, and the pay step rules for how you move within the new band. For the wider picture, read the job evaluation guide, the Agenda for Change guide, the Band 5 nurse review and the pay protection guide for what happens when a post is re-banded downwards. For the money around the move, see the pension contributions guide and the 2026/27 pay rise guide.

Sources